ArthurH 12 Posted April 25, 2024 I am aware that the cause of our lack of endfloat is almost certainly due to a problem with the shell/body/chassis, but I have posted this deliberately under Drivetrain. Our 1.6GTI was already suffering from a lack of float when we bought it in 2017, with extreme vibrations as the DS bottomed out. From memory, the standard figure is between 10 and 16mm on each side. (lets call it a nominal 13mm). we spent a lot of time (100s of hours) unsuccessfully trying to find what was bent so we could straighten it. Measuring between tooling points and comparing with known 'good' cars, swapping out subframes, driveshafts, lower arms, nothing helped. In desperation, we moved the engine towards the O/S and achieved 11mm on each side. A touch with the Armco at Pembery lost the endfloat again, moving the engine meant we now had 8mm on each side. Two years later a small prang at Donnington and we are down to 4mm. This is too low; the driveshaft destroying vibration is back. We don't want to invest more valuable time into the existing shell, and have bought a new shell, but that won't be ready until next year. So our last 'roll of the dice', to get through this season, is shorter driveshafts; I am looking for ones that will fit the 1.6GTI (BE3, standard 1.6GTI hubs so 24T/21T/M20) which is approx 9mm shorter than the standard length. OR any specific brand where the overall compressed length is that much shorter than standard. Or any way of reliably shortening one ( I very much doubt we can afford custom-made ones) I have tried the SKF website, but although the interface is one of the best I have seen, sadly the data it is returning is flawed (it is offering 25T/24T/M24) TiA Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
petert 641 Posted April 25, 2024 I’d first of all change to the larger, later CV’s which have 34 splines. These were fitted to Series 2 Mi16, GTi6 and probably many others. There are solid and hollow versions of the driveshafts, which are far stronger than 205 or 1.9L Mi16 versions. You could then shorten the driveshaft to the required length by sleeving etc. I’m sure if done properly, they’d be strong enough for your application. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Tom Fenton 1,650 Posted April 25, 2024 28 minutes ago, petert said: I’d first of all change to the larger, later CV’s which have 34 splines. These were fitted to Series 2 Mi16, GTi6 and probably many others. There are solid and hollow versions of the driveshafts, which are far stronger than 205 or 1.9L Mi16 versions. You could then shorten the driveshaft to the required length by sleeving etc. I’m sure if done properly, they’d be strong enough for your application. The 1.6 GTI uses a smaller joint and wheel bearing etc over here in the UK Peter. It would be an involved job to change them, uprights, drive flanges, wheel bearings etc 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
petert 641 Posted April 25, 2024 3 minutes ago, Tom Fenton said: The 1.6 GTI uses a smaller joint and wheel bearing etc over here in the UK Peter. It would be an involved job to change them, uprights, drive flanges, wheel bearings etc I know, but it opens up the options and has to be cheaper then custom driveshafts. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
welshpug 1,737 Posted April 25, 2024 (edited) Surely it would be far cheaper to get the shell on a jig and pull it straight again, like you said its not moved far. Edited April 25, 2024 by welshpug 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted April 25, 2024 We couldn't find anyone with a jig that was willing to do so without charging us many £100s; so as a new shell also will address some other issues, that plan is now already underway, but I won't have it ready in time. I have just 3 weeks until the next two races at Silverstone. The regulations of Classic Stock Hatch are very much focused on the 'Stock' element, so we can't change the carrier or hub or upright. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
petert 641 Posted April 27, 2024 (edited) I'm a little perplexed on this, after giving it more thought. Isn't the end float controlled by the wishbone lengths + subframe width? ie if the engine is securely located by the lower engine mount, the end float must be fixed and constant. Movement in the body would only marginally effect this. As the top of the strut position changes, there would be changes to camber & caster, and less so end float. What sort of lower mount do you use? Or mushy wishbone bushes? Edited April 27, 2024 by petert 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted April 27, 2024 Hi Peter, yes, we can not see any flaw in your logic at all. Hence the swapping out of the subframe and the wishbones with known good ones. In the case of the subframe, not only did fitting it make no difference to the end float, but it fitted effortlessly, indicating that all the subframe mounting points in the chassis rails were exactly where they should be. I didn't mention before, but although the wings are a bit battered now, the bonnet fits square to the windscreen and the wings square to the bonnet, so no indication of any trapezing. But the empirical evidence is that we are losing a few mm of end float each time a wing gets bent. In fact, if we assume a start of 26mm in total, we have now lost 17.5mm We have to run the standard 205 lower wishbones, uprights, hubs, and flanges. The current set of wishbones, including the bushes, are brand new. Regarding the drive shafts, I am aware that each manufacturer must meet certain design aspects that are 'important' to the function, e.g., overall length, journal diameters etc. But I was hoping that the overall compressed length (the point where the tripod bottoms out) may be left to the manufacturer's discretion. And out there somewhere, someone is making ones that would work for us.... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
petert 641 Posted April 28, 2024 (edited) Surely the 26mm has to remain constant? ie 13 + 13, or 6 + 20, as the engine moves? Is there a strut brace fitted? Edited April 28, 2024 by petert Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted April 28, 2024 It may help if I take you through a typical incident. I should first say my son (aka James) is a very clean driver in a non-contact formula, normally 12 or 14 races per season, but occasionally cars touch each other. At the penultimate race of last season at Donington, the car James was battling with had to take sudden avoiding action from the cars further in front and James could not avoid him. Both cars carried on, James with a broken headlight and a slightly crumpled off-side wing. For the rest of the race, James could feel the now all too familiar bottoming of the near side driveshaft on right-hand corners. Note in this instance it is the opposite side to the prang. This is true 80% of the time, it seems counterintuitive, but perhaps its a clue. Back in the paddock, we see the inner boot has split, this happens 90% of the time, I have no idea what causes it, but we have fitted many boots from many different suppliers. We check the end float, and find 2mm left on the NS DS (not enough). We fit another driveshaft, move the engine towards the OS, and balance out the end float. We now have 4.5mm on each side. In the final race of the season on the following day, we discover 4.5mm isn't enough for the fast right-handers and bottom out another drive shaft, (and another split boot). The engine moving is achieved by slotting the upper engine mount, its crude, but the only solution that has allowed the car to keep racing, when you look at the photo, remember we have to allow room for a socket. We also have to fit a spacer behind the battery tray. So the original 26mm of float has dropped in stages, each time balanced out, to the current 9mm (4.5 + 4.5) The regulations forbid any strut brace. https://750mc.co.uk/ugc-1/1/1/0/2024_final_regs_-_classic_stock_hatc.pdf We do keep a close eye on the camber, this has never been affected by any of these incidents.... This aligns with the fit of the bonnet. I now have a plan to shorten a drive shaft, but need to strip it down completely. I am baffled by the strange circlip on the inboard joint, rather than 'eyes' it just has two 'horns' , The circlip moves very freely, which is good, but I'm finding it much more awkward to push those horns apart. I've struggled with long nose pliers, but still can't slide the spline. Am I missing something? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted April 29, 2024 I thought I'd better include a picture of the circlip 'horns' I was trying to describe. Is there a particular technique for holding these open? While drifting out the spline.... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Tom Fenton 1,650 Posted April 30, 2024 11 hours ago, ArthurH said: I thought I'd better include a picture of the circlip 'horns' I was trying to describe. Is there a particular technique for holding these open? While drifting out the spline.... I'd try a pair of external 90 degree circlip pliers and try to open the clip up with those. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted May 1, 2024 Thanks Tom, I did as you suggested and it made all the difference, I had the shaft out within a few minutes. Any idea as to how I remove the ballbearing 'cluster' from the housing? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted May 20, 2024 I have been thinking a lot about how these components bolt together, and I do appreciate the bearing isn't shown in these pictures, but I am still concerned about which surfaces are clamped together when the hub nut is tightened. I had expected the end of the flange (green) and the end of the DS housing (blue) would be the two clamped surfaces, but the first photo shows it as far on as it will slide. The second photo shows what is clamped, the internal splines press on the raised edge (orange). IMHO this is not good design, there is little control over how much those hardened splines will sink into the housing edge. Have I got this wong? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
welshpug 1,737 Posted May 21, 2024 (edited) Double Post Edited May 21, 2024 by welshpug Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
welshpug 1,737 Posted May 21, 2024 12 hours ago, ArthurH said: Have I got this wong? Yes, they clamp the bearing. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Tom Fenton 1,650 Posted May 21, 2024 The drive flange and register on the cv joint clamp the inner race of the wheel bearing. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted May 21, 2024 Ah, thanks guys, the (QH) bearing width is listed as 34mm (albiet mine is a fraction less), but the current clamped gap between the back of the flange and the front of the (modified) DS housing is 38mm. I will need to relieve the edge I marked in orange by 5mm so that it clamps the bearing properly Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
greenclaws1975 4 1 Cars Posted June 6, 2024 'swapping out subframes, driveshafts, lower arms, nothing helped' My 1/2p If the shell was bent the castor and camber angle would be incorrect i would have thought.. Have you measured the distance between the bolt holes across the strut towers...somebody posted a body data sheet on here. have you changed the struts and hub carriers...the carriers aren't very strong a blow to the wheel can easily bend them Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted December 19, 2025 As I mentioned towards the beginning of this topic, I saw the shortening of a driveshaft as a temporary sticking plaster to get us through the '24 season, after which we would reshell the car. The reshelling took place over the 24/25 winter, and my son has had a lot of success with the car this year. However, one big disappointment when we fitted the engine/box/subrame/wishbones into the new shell, was to discover that it hadn't made the slightest difference to the endfloat issue. At the beginning of this season, we had no spare endfloat at all. As James kept the car from any contact whatsoever (until the final round at Oulton Park - documented elsewhere on this site), this minimal endfloat was enough to keep racing. However, I have just re-fitted the engine after its biennial rebuild and have swapped the punctured gearbox casing. Our customary check of the endfloat shows we currently have 8 and 4 mm - not enough. I'd like to resurrect this thread, as I am at my wits' end as to where the end float disappears to. I'll start by summarizing the situation to avoid the need to read this thread all the way from the start. When James bought the 1.6 205GTI in 2017, it was already a race car. It races in the 750MC Classic Stock Hatch championship, with a lot of emphasis on 'Stock'. A blueprinted engine, standard suspension mounting points, standard wishbones, hub, and uprights. Standard, gearbox, and final drive (inc ratios). What had been done (and seems to be generally accepted) is that Bridgecraft had machined/sleeved the standard hub to increase the negative camber. When he first got the car, we immediately had a problem with the NS driveshaft bottoming out under cornering load. Due to a lack of endfloat, the inner 'tripod' is forced into contact with the inside of the inner cup. After a racing lap, it will have gouged out the cup and filled the grease with swarf. But it is hard to complete a racing lap as the vibration through the corners is horrific. We couldn't see why the problem was occurring, but back then, the solution was relatively simple. We elongated the hole in the upper OS engine mount and used the slots in the battery tray mount to move the engine over to the OS of the car. This evened out the endfloat, giving us 12mm* on each side of the car, and the problem disappeared (for a while). We became very slick at measuring it. With the hubnut removed, we push the DS from behind the hub to maximise the protrusion from the hub and measure with a vernier. It is normally 19.4mm. We then push the DS back towards the diff, collapsing its internal spring. It bottoms out with a very definite 'clunk', and we measure the protrusion from the hub again. The new figure is subtracted from the first, and the difference is the end float. We always measure with the car at the same angle on the same axle stands. *IIRC the Haynes figure for the end-float is between 10 and 16mm each side. We know we had lost a little bit due to the machining of the hub/-ve camber, and perhaps a bit more due to the lower-than-standard ride height, but still within tolerance. Over the years, the car was involved in a few prangs, typical of very close racing; only one of them, that involved ARMCO at Pembery, was a DNF. But each time we found the endfloat was getting less. 4.7mm seems to be the absolute minimum; any less and it will bottom out. We had to move the engine even further to the OS of the car, even grinding off some of the webbing from the upper engine mount to avoid it touching the inner wing. Because these reductions seemed to correspond with collisions, albeit sometimes very minor ones, you can see why we assumed something, somewhere was getting bent. I shudder to think how many hundreds of hours the two of us spent looking for where this was. We could not find anything wrong with the shell, having measured as carefully as we could between tooling holes and comparing with other 205s. We tried a different, known good, subframe, different wishbones, and many different DSs. The GAZ (Leder) struts have been serviced and checked for straightness. The negative camber has been accurately checked several times over the years; it is unchanged. We understand that apart from the inner wing top mounts (in this context), the shell doesn't play any part in the front suspension geometry; it is governed by the subframe and wishbones. But although we couldn't find the reason, we had to do something. In the end, we decided to reshell the car (a non-trivial task....) So, having reshelled and then finding we still had the barest minimum of endfloat, you can imagine the disappointment. But at least it took that 'off the table'. One thing has changed; I don't know if this is a clue. When we first started moving the engine, the results were highly predictable. If we moved the engine 2mm to the OS, the OS endfloat would reduce by 2mm, and the NS endfloat would increase by 2mm. We found towards the 'end' of the first shell, and now with the new one, that is no longer necessarily the case. We can move the engine 3mm to the OS, and the NS endfloat only increases by 1mm. I talk of moving the engine as though it is an easy fix - but the engine is now 8 or 9mm further to the OS than when we started, and the (ground down!) upper engine mount is only a fraction of a mm from the inner wing. We have run out.... That is why when I say we have 8mm on the OS, we are unable to share any of that with the NS. The big question - Why do we no longer have the 12 +12 that we previously had with the same suspension components? Where has it all gone? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Leslie green 166 Posted December 19, 2025 Are the driveshafts genuine ? as it has to be either a drive shaft or lower arm issue , its definitely 205 bottom arms not 309 ones which look similar ? 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted December 19, 2025 We have tried a selection of DSs. Interestingly, we found them to be remarkably consistent in their dimensions, in particular, the minimum 'collapsed' length. The lower arms/wishbones are 205 - the different webbing is a clear giveaway to the slightly longer but illegal 309 wishbones (which the technical scrutineers are aware of). The issue is that the endfloat continues to reduce even when all of these components are unchanged. It is only because it reduces that we look for (and fail to find) shorter versions to get around the problem. To get the endfloat back, I would need to find a driveshaft that was 10-12mm shorter than the standard 205 DS. But why? 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
PhilNW 67 Posted December 23, 2025 (edited) Are you using the right hub /bearing, the drive shaft should be mating on the inner face of the wheel bearing, see engineers blue on photo , From what I can seen on the previous photos the shaft does not appear to be going into the splines on the hub enough thus reducing the end foat Edited December 23, 2025 by PhilNW Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ArthurH 12 Posted December 23, 2025 Thanks. Is it this picture you are referring to? On 5/20/2024 at 6:51 PM, ArthurH said: I understood from Mei and Tom that the bearing would be clamped before the gap between the blue and green lines was reduced to the size shown in this photo. I have replaced the bearing, and experienced the same end float issue before and after doing so. That doesn't necessarily mean it is the correct bearing, but I'm very confident it is. It is a standard 1.6 GTI flange. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Spesh 35 1 Cars Posted December 23, 2025 I recently had an issue with new febi drive flanges having the incorrect taper which meant my driveshafts didnt seat fully, not sure its what you have because mine failed to correctly clamp the bearing causing almost instant failure of the bearing. Maybe I would have had float issues from it but I didnt really get to drive it in anger so didnt get that far. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites